Talk:Zoriah
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
[edit] Misleading notes
In this series of edits, I removed notes that presented links. If you say that your biographee X had a certain relationship Y with an entity Z, then your note after this should normally verify this entire proposition; it shouldn't merely say something else about entity Z.
This article is essentially unreferenced, and deserves the "Unreferenced" tag, which I placed on it earlier. -- Hoary 06:43, 12 September 2007 (UTC)
- Some editor has now pretty much reverted my changes. He or she has (i) deleted a lot of FACT tags, (ii) added some "references" that aren't actually references, and also (iii) added one or two genuine references. But (iii) is so overwhelmed by (i) and (ii) that I felt no compunction in reverting the lot.
- If there are genuine references for specific claims, feel free to add them. That the photographer himself claims to have won this or that award or achieved some other feat is not a credible reference. That a particular organization has a website is not a reference for a claim that it had such and such a relationship with this photographer. Et cetera. -- Hoary 06:35, 28 September 2007 (UTC)
-
- Another IP did the same thing again. I reverted the edit, for the reasons explained above. -- Hoary 06:20, 7 October 2007 (UTC)

